Machinery, Proofreading, Error: The Words No Naturalist Can Stop Using

Every Sentence Says Otherwise — SmithForChrist apologetics header on purpose language and naturalism

Nothing in nature is for anything — and nobody can write a sentence about nature without saying it is

Open any cell biology textbook written in the last forty years and count the purpose words on a single page.

The ribosome reads the message. DNA polymerase proofreads its own work and corrects errors. The kidney has a function. Mitochondria are the cell’s powerhouses. Motor proteins walk along tracks, transporting cargo to its destination. Cells run on machinery, pumps, gates, channels, signals, messengers, checkpoints, quality control, and a genetic code.

Now here is the claim I want to defend. On strict naturalism — the view that matter in motion is all there has ever been and no mind stands behind any of it — not one of those words can be literally true.

A pump is for moving fluid because somebody wanted fluid moved. An error is a departure from a result something was supposed to produce. A code is a convention between a sender and a receiver who agreed on what the symbols mean. Matter in motion has no supposed-to. Atoms do not have jobs. If naturalism is true, the most useful vocabulary in the life sciences is systematically false.

The Honest Answer, Stated Fairly

Naturalists have noticed this. Philosophers of biology have worked on it for fifty years, and any apologetic that pretends otherwise is swinging at a straw man.

The standard answer is called the selected-effects or etiological account of function. On this view, to say the heart’s function is to pump blood means something like: ancestral hearts that pumped blood helped their bearers survive and reproduce, and that is why hearts are here now. Function is the effect that explains why a trait was selected. Different versions of this have been developed carefully by serious thinkers. Alongside it runs the pragmatic move — that treating organisms as designed is simply an enormously successful predictive strategy, close enough to true to pay its way.

Give it its due. That is not a dodge. It is a real proposal, it is internally coherent, and it genuinely explains why purpose language is useful. Credit where it belongs.

It still does not reach, and there are three places where you can watch it come up short.


One: Selection Explains Persistence, Not Aim

Natural selection is a report on what survived. Survival is what happened. It is not what anything was trying to do.

Take the outcome of a process and relabel it the goal of the process, and you have read the arrow backwards. Sand that falls through a sieve was not for falling through. Rivers are not for reaching the sea, even though every river that exists is doing it. The pattern explains itself without anybody aiming at anything — which is exactly the naturalist’s point, and exactly why he cannot then collect the word aim on the way out.

Two: “Error” Is a Normative Word, and History Cannot Supply a Norm

This is the one that does not come apart.

A selection history can tell you what usually happened. It cannot tell you what ought to happen. Those are two different kinds of statement, and no amount of the first adds up to the second.

When DNA polymerase inserts the wrong base, the selected-effects account can say: that is statistically unusual compared to ancestral performance. What it cannot say is that it is wrong. And yet the entire enterprise of cancer research is built on that word. Mutation is a defect. Repair enzymes restore a correct sequence. A cell line is malfunctioning. A protein is misfolded.

You cannot squeeze defective out of rare. Rare is a frequency. Defective is a judgment against a standard, and a standard has to be set by somebody. This is the old point about is and ought, aimed where people rarely aim it: not at ethics, but at a laboratory bench on a Tuesday afternoon.

Three: The Vocabulary Will Not Come Out

Try the experiment. Take one paragraph about protein synthesis and rewrite it with every purpose word stripped out and nothing teleological smuggled back in. No reads. No code. No error. No transports, no in order to, no machinery, no function.

What comes out is unreadable, and worse than unreadable — it has lost information working scientists actually use. That is the tell. The purpose language is not decoration laid over the real description. It is the description, and it is how the discoveries got made. Nobody found DNA proofreading by cataloguing what molecules merely do. Somebody found it by asking what the cell is trying to get right, and then going to look.

A man who has to use a vocabulary his own metaphysics forbids is borrowing. He may borrow for a career, and the work he does with it may be excellent and true. What he cannot do is claim he owns the account.

Some Do Bite the Bullet. Nobody Lives There.

To be fair, a few philosophers are consistent about this. They are eliminativists about function: purpose talk is strictly false, a convenient fiction, and we should know it when we use it. That is at least honest, and it deserves respect rather than mockery.

But notice two things about that position. First, no laboratory in the world operates on it for a single afternoon. Second — and this is the deeper problem — a “convenient fiction” is a strange thing to call the most reliable predictive instrument in the discipline. When a fiction keeps turning out to be right about things nobody had looked at yet, intellectual honesty eventually has to ask whether it is a fiction at all.

Scripture Does Not Argue for Purpose. It Assigns It.

Here is what I find striking. The Bible never builds a case that things have purposes. It opens by handing them out.

And God said, Let there be lights in the firmament of the heaven to divide the day from the night; and let them be for signs, and for seasons, and for days, and years.

Genesis 1:14 (KJV)

Count the fors in one verse. Before the fourth day is over, the heavenly bodies have assignments.

For thus saith the LORD that created the heavens; God himself that formed the earth and made it; he hath established it, he created it not in vain, he formed it to be inhabited: I am the LORD; and there is none else.

Isaiah 45:18 (KJV)

“Not in vain” is the key phrase. The word behind it means empty, pointless, waste — the same emptiness the earth is described with before God begins to order it. Isaiah says the universe is not that. It was formed to be something.

For by him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him, and for him.

Colossians 1:16 (KJV)

On this account, function is not projected onto nature by a useful fiction. It is read off of nature, because an intending mind put it there first. Which means the biologist’s vocabulary is not a charming mistake. It is accurate reporting — and he is the only man in the building who cannot say where the accuracy comes from.

One clarification, since believers divide here. Christians argue among themselves about mechanism and timing — how long the creation took, how much change descent accounts for, how to read the days of Genesis 1. Brothers on both sides of those questions hold real arguments that deserve real answers, not caricatures. None of that is what is at stake in this post. Young-earth and old-earth creationists alike affirm the thing the naturalist cannot: that the universe was made on purpose, by Someone, for something.

The Word You Cannot Stop Using About Yourself

A man can tell you over dinner that purpose is a story we tell ourselves and that the universe does not care. Then follow him for a week.

He will say his job is pointless — which requires a point. He will be bitter that his father wasted his life — which requires something a life is for. He will say his marriage is not working, and that is a function word. He will be furious when a man does not do what a father is supposed to do.

Nobody actually lives in a world without for. You can deny it at the level of the ribosome. You cannot deny it at the level of your Tuesday.

For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse.

Romans 1:20 (KJV)

“The things that are made.” Paul does not say the things that are here. Made things are things made for, and that is the piece of evidence he says nobody gets to plead ignorance about.

What You Were For

This is where the argument stops being an argument.

If you were made for something and you have spent twenty years on something else, that is not a philosophy problem. The Bible has an older word for it, and the word is lost — not destroyed, not worthless, but out of the place it belongs and unable to get back on its own.

Colossians says all things were created by him and for him. Four verses later it says something more: that it pleased the Father to reconcile all things to himself through him, “having made peace through the blood of his cross.” The One who assigned the purpose came in person to recover the creature that failed it. That is not merely a worldview with enough resources to justify the word function. That is the Person the word was always pointing at.

The naturalist and the Christian are standing over the same cell, using the same words, and both of them are right about what they see. Only one of them can tell you where the words came from.


Teaching the Word. Watching the Times.
— SmithForChrist

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top