Somewhere a Child Bore the Image Its Parents Did Not

A Smith For Christ devotional header reading: Somewhere the Image Began. He Was Formed, Not Found.

If humanity arrived gradually, then the image of God arrived on a particular day, in a particular individual — and someone’s mother did not have it. That question deserves a straight answer.

Most arguments about origins get stuck on rocks and radiometric dates. This one has nothing to do with either.

Set the geology aside entirely. Grant, for the length of this article, every date and every lineage. The question that remains is theological, and it is the hardest one theistic evolution has to carry: who was the first creature to bear the image of God, and what were its parents?

That is not a cheap shot. It is the question the Bible itself forces, because of how much weight Scripture hangs on that one phrase.

The Image Is Not a Spectrum

So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them.

Genesis 1:27 (KJV)

Scripture never describes the image as a trait that comes in degrees. It is never partial, never emerging, never more present in one man than another. It is a status — and the Bible treats it as a legal one. Watch what God builds on it after the flood:

Whoso sheddeth man’s blood, by man shall his blood be shed: for in the image of God made he man.

Genesis 9:6 (KJV)

The capital sanction for homicide rests on the image. Not on intelligence. Not on tool use or language or self-awareness. The reason killing a man is a different category of act from killing an animal is that one of them bears the image and the other does not. James reaches for the same ground when he says we bless God and curse men “which are made after the similitude of God.”

So the image is a hard boundary with consequences attached. Which means it has an edge. And an edge, in a continuous lineage, is a problem.

The Best Version of the Other View

Let me state the theistic evolutionist’s answer as strongly as he would state it, because he has thought about this and he is not a fool.

He says the image of God is not a biological property at all. It is not encoded anywhere, it cannot be found on a scan, and it did not evolve — because it was never the kind of thing that could. The image is a conferral: a calling, a covenant standing, a relationship that God grants. Therefore God is entirely free to take a creature produced by ordinary descent and confer that standing on it at a moment of His choosing. Some in this camp propose that God did exactly that with one historical individual inside an existing population — a real man, divinely addressed, made covenant head of the race. Others hold that God conferred the image on a whole group at once.

That is a coherent proposal, and it deserves to be granted what it earns. Scripture does present the image as God’s gift rather than man’s achievement. Nothing in Genesis suggests Adam generated his own dignity.

But notice what that answer has just conceded, and it is a great deal.

The Discontinuity Does Not Disappear. It Moves.

If the image is conferred, then the conferral is an event. Sudden. Non-biological. Unobservable by any instrument. Which means theistic evolution has not removed the sharp break between man and beast at all. It has relocated it — out of biology and into an act of God so abrupt that no fossil, no gene, and no gradual process had anything to do with it.

Hold that still for a second. The entire appeal of the view was that it required no special divine intervention in the story of life. And here, at the one point that matters most for human worth, it requires precisely that: a direct, discrete, miraculous act with no natural mechanism whatsoever.

So we are no longer arguing about whether God acted suddenly and specially to make man what he is. Both sides now say He did. We are only arguing about what He did it to, and whether the account He gave us of it is reliable.

The Household Problem

Now take the individual-conferral version and walk it into a real household.

There is a first bearer. He has a mother and a father who are not bearers. He may have brothers who are not bearers. By Genesis 9:6, his life is protected by divine sanction and theirs is not. If he kills his own brother, heaven treats it one way; if his brother kills him, heaven treats it another. The men hunting beside him in the same band, speaking the same words, burying their dead with the same grief, stand on opposite sides of the most consequential line in creation — and nothing visible marks which side anyone is on.

And then: whom does he marry? If his wife is not a bearer, the image passes to his children through a mother who did not have it. If she is a bearer, then the conferral was not to one man but to at least two, and we are back to a group.

The group version avoids the household problem, which is a real advantage, and honesty requires saying so. But it pays for that relief at the register Paul is standing at. Paul’s argument does not run on a population. It runs on a man, singular, set opposite another man, singular: “the first man Adam,” “the last Adam,” sin entering by one and righteousness by one. Collapse the first term into a committee and the parallel that carries the gospel loses its symmetry.

What the Text Actually Says Happened

Against all of this, Genesis is not vague. It is almost uncomfortably specific.

And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.

Genesis 2:7 (KJV)

Formed. Breathed into. Became. The man is not described as receiving a new title while continuing a line; he is described as beginning. And then the woman is not formed separately from the ground at all but taken out of the man — and the New Testament reasons from that order as a matter of fact, not of poetry:

For Adam was first formed, then Eve.

1 Timothy 2:13 (KJV)

Paul is not decorating an argument there. He is resting one on a sequence. And when he preaches to philosophers in Athens — men with their own origins stories — he does not hedge about the unity of the race:

And hath made of one blood all nations of men for to dwell on all the face of the earth…

Acts 17:26 (KJV)

Of one blood. That is the ground of human equality in Scripture, and it is the reason the Bible has no category for a superior branch of humanity. Every racial hierarchy ever constructed has needed a gradient where the Bible put a single family. The doctrine that all men descend from one man and one woman, both bearing the image, is not an incidental detail of Genesis. It is load-bearing ethics.

Where Brothers Still Stand Together

This is an in-house argument, and it should be conducted like one. Believers who hold an evolutionary account of origins are not trying to smuggle atheism into the church. Many of them confess the Fall, the authority of Scripture, the deity of Christ, and a bodily resurrection, and they will stand with you at the judgment seat. The disagreement is about mechanism and about hermeneutics — which is serious, and is not the same as a disagreement about the gospel.

So the question to press is not are you a real Christian. It is narrower and more useful than that: what controls the reading? If Genesis 2 can be reduced to theological poetry because an external account requires it, what is the principle that keeps Genesis 3 from going the same way, or Romans 5, or the empty tomb? Every believer needs an answer to that, and “the consensus moved” is not one. Consensus is not a hermeneutic.

The Answer the Dust Gives

Here is why this is not an academic parlor game, and why it lands on you personally.

If your worth is a status conferred somewhere back in a lineage nobody can locate, then your worth is a rumor. You cannot verify it, you cannot feel it, and on a bad night you will not believe it. But if God formed a man from dust and breathed into him, and you are that man’s son, then your dignity is not an inference from your abilities. It is an inheritance from your Maker. It does not rise when you perform and it does not fall when you fail, and no one can revoke it by reclassifying you.

And it goes further than dignity. The God who stooped into dust to make a man stooped into flesh to save him. The second Adam did not arrive as a conferral upon an existing line. He was born, bodily, into the family He came to buy back — which is exactly why He can stand in your place. The whole rescue runs on real men in a real line with a real fall behind them.

Someone had to be first. Every view agrees. Genesis tells you his name, where he was put, what he was told, and what he did with it. That is not a gap in the account. That is the account.


Teaching the Word. Watching the Times.
— SmithForChrist

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top