Two Men Prayed. One Went Home Justified.

Devotional header reading: Two Men Prayed the Same Hour. One Went Home Justified.

Two men prayed in the same building at the same hour. Only one of them went home right with God.

Jesus told a story about two men at prayer. One of them was, by every visible measure, the better man. He was more disciplined, more generous, more careful, more religious. If you had been standing in the temple that day and somebody asked you which of the two was right with God, you would have pointed at him, and you would have been wrong.

That is the whole point of the parable, and it is also the reason people have been misreading it for two thousand years. Most of us hear it and immediately begin thanking God we are not like that Pharisee — which, if you catch it, is the Pharisee’s prayer with new vocabulary.

Luke tells you the target before he tells you the story, which is unusual, and worth noticing.

And he spake this parable unto certain which trusted in themselves that they were righteous, and despised others. (KJV)

Two symptoms, one disease. Trusting in yourself and looking down on other people are not two separate problems that happen to travel together. They are the same problem seen from two angles. The moment your standing with God rests on your performance, you need a scale. And a scale needs somebody on the other side of it.

The Prayer That Was All True

The Pharisee stood and prayed thus with himself, God, I thank thee, that I am not as other men are, extortioners, unjust, adulterers, or even as this publican. I fast twice in the week, I give tithes of all that I possess. (KJV)

Here is what makes this uncomfortable: nothing he said was a lie. He really did fast twice a week. The law required one fast a year; he was doing about a hundred. He really did tithe everything, down to the garden herbs. He was not an extortioner. He was not an adulterer. If you had audited the man, the books would have balanced.

And he was right about the publican, too. Tax collectors in that world were not misunderstood civil servants. They bought the right to collect for Rome and made their living on whatever they could squeeze above the quota. The man at the back of the temple had almost certainly ruined neighbours for profit.

So the Pharisee’s facts were accurate, his morals were superior, and his religion was real. And he went home lost. Understand what that means before you go any further: it is entirely possible to be correct about your own record, correct about somebody else’s, and still be standing outside.

Look at four words Luke drops in without comment — prayed thus with himself. The man is addressing God and talking to himself. Everything in the prayer points inward. Count the pronouns: I thank, I am not, I fast, I give, all that I possess. There is one request in it. There is no request in it. He came to file a report, not to ask for anything, because a man who thinks the account is in credit has nothing to ask for.

The Prayer That Was Seven Words

And the publican, standing afar off, would not lift up so much as his eyes unto heaven, but smote upon his breast, saying, God be merciful to me a sinner. (KJV)

Every detail here is a posture, and every posture is an argument. Standing afar off — he knows he has no business near the holy place. Would not lift up so much as his eyes — the normal Jewish posture for prayer was eyes and hands raised; this man cannot do it. Smote upon his breast — a gesture of grief so violent it was mostly reserved for mourning the dead. He is at his own funeral.

Then the words. In English it reads as a simple plea for mercy, and it is, but the Greek verb underneath is sharper than that. It is not the ordinary word for pity. It is the word built on the mercy seat — the blood-covered lid of the ark where atonement was made once a year. The man is not saying go easy on me. He is saying: God, be propitiated toward me. Deal with me at the place where blood is applied, because that is the only place I can be dealt with.

And the article he uses is worth having. Not a sinner, one among many. The definite article: the sinner. He is not comparing. He has stopped counting other people entirely. In his accounting there is exactly one guilty man in that building and he is it.

That is what the Pharisee could not do, and it had nothing to do with intelligence or sincerity. The Pharisee could not say it because he was still looking sideways.

The Verdict

I tell you, this man went down to his house justified rather than the other: for every one that exalteth himself shall be abased; and he that humbleth himself shall be exalted. (KJV)

Justified. That word is not a feeling and it is not a process. It is a courtroom verdict. It means declared righteous — not made gradually better, not put on probation, not given a second chance to try harder. Declared right, in full, on the spot.

Which means the man who walked out of that temple with a clean legal standing before God was the one who had not improved by a single degree between walking in and walking out. He fixed nothing. He promised nothing. He repaid nobody yet. He asked to be dealt with at the blood, and he was.

And note the timing: went down to his house justified. Not eventually. Not after a probationary period. He was right with God before he reached the bottom of the temple steps.

Where This Lands on You

The mistake most people make with this parable is assuming the Pharisee’s prayer requires religion. It does not. It only requires a comparison. Most men who pray it today have never fasted in their lives.

It sounds like this. I’m not perfect, but I’m not like him. At least I never walked out on my kids. I’ve done some things, but compared to what goes on out there? I’m basically a good person.

Every one of those sentences is doing exactly what the Pharisee did: establishing a standing before God on a curve. And here is the problem with grading on a curve — you do not set it. God is not comparing you to your neighbour, your brother-in-law, or the man on the news. He is not grading the class. There is one standard, it is Himself, and it does not move to accommodate the field.

So the question this parable asks is not are you a good man. The question is: when you pray, are you presenting evidence or asking for mercy? Because those are the only two prayers there are, and only one of them gets answered.

Be honest about which one is yours. If you find that you cannot pray without quietly referencing somebody who is worse, you are still standing up front with the pronouns.

Why God Can Do This

There is an obvious objection here, and it deserves an answer rather than a shrug. How can a holy God simply declare a guilty man righteous? If a human judge did that, we would call it corruption, not mercy.

The answer is that the publican’s word was better than he knew. He asked God to deal with him at the place of blood, and God had every intention of doing exactly that — not with the blood of a yearly animal, but with His own Son.

Being justified freely by his grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus: whom God hath set forth to be a propitiation through faith in his blood … that he might be just, and the justifier of him which believeth in Jesus. (KJV)

Just, and the justifier. Both at once. The guilt was not waived, it was transferred. The verdict was not softened, it was satisfied. That is why the publican could walk out of the temple justified without having fixed one thing about his life: somebody else was going to pay for what he could not.

But to him that worketh not, but believeth on him that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is counted for righteousness. (KJV)

Read the phrase slowly: him that justifieth the ungodly. Not the improved. Not the sincere. Not the trying. The ungodly. That is the only category the gospel has ever had a cure for.

Go Home Justified

If you have been running your own version of the Pharisee’s prayer — and most of us have, in one form or another, for years — the way out is not to work up a better record. You already know your record. That is not your problem. Your problem is that you have been submitting it.

Stop submitting it. Stand where the publican stood, stop looking sideways, and ask God to deal with you at the blood. That prayer has never once been refused.

There is no fasting schedule in this parable, no tithe, no list. There is a man who had nothing to offer and knew it, and he is the one who went home right with God.


Teaching the Word. Watching the Times.
— SmithForChrist

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top