Non-Binary Is Not in the Bible: The Binary Choice of Christ in Luke 11


Non-Binary Is Not in the Bible: The Binary Choice of Christ in Luke 11

Modern culture has created a kaleidoscope of gender identities. What used to be understood as a simple, God-given reality—male and female—has now expanded into a long list that grows almost weekly. Today we hear terms such as non-binary, genderfluid, demiboy, demigirl, agender, bigender, pangender, two-spirit, genderqueer, polygender, intergender, and many more. Some online lists now contain over 100 “gender identities,” each with its own symbols, pronouns, and ideological commitments.

Behind these labels is a cultural claim:
“Human identity is not fixed; it is self-constructed. Gender is a spectrum, not a design.”

But Scripture presents a very different story.

The Word of God does not describe humanity as a self-invented spectrum. The Bible does not paint identity as fluid, ambiguous, or ever-expanding. Instead, God reveals human identity as a creation of His design—binary, purposeful, and good.

And this is not a small theological point. It is foundational.

Before we arrive at Luke 11, where Jesus makes a bold declaration that spiritual life is also binary, we must begin where God begins—in Genesis, where identity itself is defined.


1. The Foundation: God Created Humanity Binary

The opening chapter of Scripture makes one of the most radical, enduring, and countercultural statements in human history:

“So God created man in His own image;
in the image of God He created him;
male and female He created them.”
—Genesis 1:27 (NKJV)

Three truths flow directly from this verse:

**Truth #1 — God created humanity.

We did not create ourselves.**

Identity is received, not invented.
It comes from God, not from feelings, preferences, or social trends.

Truth #2 — Image-bearing is linked to embodiment.

We bear God’s image as male and female, not as a spectrum of self-designed categories. Both reflect God, but in distinct ways. God is not divided into genders; rather, male and female together reflect God’s glorious design for humanity.

Truth #3 — God created only two genders.

Scripture never records God creating:

  • a third category,
  • a fluid category,
  • an “identity spectrum,”
  • or a self-select, self-defined system.

There is no verse where God says:

“Male, female… and whatever else you feel.”

Instead, God speaks with crystal clarity: two genders only.

Jesus Himself affirms this in the New Testament:

“He who made them at the beginning ‘made them male and female.’”
—Matthew 19:4 (NKJV)

God’s design is binary.
Biology is binary.
Creation is binary.
Identity is binary.

But now we must ask a deeper question:

Why does Satan work so hard to blur what God made clear?

Because identity confusion leads to spiritual confusion.
And spiritual confusion blinds people to the most important binary decision in life.

This is where Luke 11 enters the story.


2. Transitioning to Luke 11: Culture Loves Spectrums—Jesus Declares a Binary

Our culture insists:

  • Gender is a spectrum.
  • Truth is a spectrum.
  • Morality is a spectrum.
  • Spirituality is a spectrum.
  • Identity is a spectrum.

But in Luke 11:14–23, Jesus declares something shocking:

There is no spiritual spectrum.

There is no spiritual neutrality.
There are no “half-decisions.”
There are no “in-between believers.”
There are no middle categories.

Where culture multiplies identities and categories, Jesus reduces everything to one ultimate dividing line.

Just as God created male or female, Jesus says you are spiritually either:

  • with Him,
    or
  • against Him.

There are no shades of gray.

There are no “non-binary Christians.”
There are no “half-Christian identities.”
There are no “spiritual spectrums.”

Jesus presents a binary reality, and He does it with the force of a lightning strike.

Let’s look at the text.


3. Luke 11:14–23 — Jesus Confronts a Confused Crowd

The Setting

Jesus casts out a demon, and instead of celebrating, the people respond with accusations, confusion, and divided opinions.

Some accuse Him of using demonic power.
Others demand more signs.
And all of them reveal the deepest issue—not a misunderstanding of miracles, but a misunderstanding of spiritual allegiance.


3.1 Luke 11:14

“And He was casting out a demon, and it was mute. So it was, when the demon had gone out, that the mute spoke; and the multitudes marveled.

Jesus performs an undeniable miracle. Something only God can do. The people recognize the supernatural, but they respond incorrectly.

This is the same mistake our culture makes today with identity.

People see God’s design in creation—male and female—and yet reinterpret it through a cultural lens. They acknowledge the supernatural but reject the meaning behind it.

The miracle was clear.
The meaning was rejected.


3.2 Luke 11:15

“But some of them said, ‘He casts out demons by Beelzebub, the ruler of the demons.’”

This accusation reveals spiritual blindness.
They have seen good and called it evil.
They have seen God’s power and claimed it came from Satan.

This confusion mirrors today’s identity debate.

Culture insists:

  • What God calls good is restrictive.
  • What God calls male and female is too rigid.
  • What God calls truth is intolerant.
  • What God calls sin is celebrated.

Spiritual confusion always distorts creation.


3.3 Luke 11:16

“Others, testing Him, sought from Him a sign from heaven.

They demand more proof even after seeing the truth.

This is the heart of unbelief.

Unbelief does not lack evidence;
it lacks surrender.

The same is true with gender identity.

The evidence for biological sex is overwhelming.
The biblical teaching is clear.
The design is unmistakable.

But culture demands that God “prove” Himself again, because the real issue is not information—it is submission.


3.4 Luke 11:17

“But He, knowing their thoughts, said to them: ‘Every kingdom divided against itself is brought to desolation, and a house divided against a house falls.’”

Jesus exposes their incoherent thinking.

A kingdom cannot operate on contradictions.
A house cannot survive in confusion.
A belief system cannot stand on self-created definitions.

God is a God of order, not confusion.
Culture is a culture of confusion, not order.

When society abandons God’s binary design for gender, it inevitably collapses into division, conflict, and identity chaos.

Divided houses fall.
Divided hearts fall.
Divided identities fall.


3.5 Luke 11:18–19

Jesus dismantles their accusations with logic and authority.

If Satan fought against Satan, his kingdom would implode.
If Jesus were using demonic power, the demons would be destroying themselves.

Jesus’ point is simple:
Your worldview is inconsistent and your reasoning is broken.

This is exactly the state of modern identity theory.

Culture says:

  • Gender is fluid, but some genders are fixed.
  • Gender is self-defined, but pronouns must be enforced.
  • Biology doesn’t matter, except when it does.
  • Identity is personal, unless others disagree.

It is a house divided.

And Jesus says:
That kind of thinking collapses.


3.6 Luke 11:20

“But if I cast out demons with the finger of God, surely the kingdom of God has come upon you.”

Jesus tells them:

“You are watching the kingdom right in front of you.
Your confusion is not due to lack of evidence—it is due to lack of faith.”

The issue is not proof.
It is not miracles.
It is not logic.

It is allegiance.

Just like today.

The issue with gender identity is ultimately not about sociology, psychology, or personal expression—it is about allegiance to the Creator.

Either we submit to God’s design, or we reject it.

There is no middle ground.


3.7 Luke 11:21–22

Jesus uses a battle metaphor.

A strong man guards his house—Satan holding people captive.
But a stronger Man comes—Jesus—who overpowers him, frees the captives, and establishes His kingdom.

This section teaches a huge spiritual truth:

Jesus is stronger than confusion, deception, identity distortion, and the lies of culture.

But freedom requires decision.
Deliverance requires allegiance.
Salvation requires surrender.

And that brings us to the key verse.


3.8 Luke 11:23 — The Heart of the Passage

“He who is not with Me is against Me, and he who does not gather with Me scatters.”

Here is the spiritual binary.

There are only two categories of people in the world:

1. Those who are with Christ.

  1. Those who are against Christ.

There is no third option.

No neutral position.
No “undecided zone.”
No “non-binary spiritual category.”
No “I like Jesus but don’t follow Him.”
No “I believe in God but not the Bible.”
No “I’m spiritual but not religious.”
No spectrum.

Jesus draws a line as clear as Genesis 1:27.

Just as gender is binary—male and female—
spiritual allegiance is binary—saved or lost, light or dark, in Christ or not.

There is no “in between.”

And Jesus illustrates this with an image we all understand:


4. Binary Spirituality: Light and Electricity

Electricity is binary.
A light switch is binary.
A circuit is binary.

It is on or off.

Not “kind of on.”
Not “half-powered.”
Not “in a spectrum of illumination.”

Just on or off.

Jesus says the human soul works the same way.

We are all born “off.”

Born in sin.
Born spiritually dead.
Born separated from God.
Born without the Light of Christ.

But Jesus came to turn us “on.”

He came to:

  • give life,
  • restore identity,
  • reveal truth,
  • defeat darkness,
  • and turn the light back on inside us.

This is exactly what John 1 says:

“The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not comprehend it.”
—John 1:5

And Paul echoes it:

“For you were once darkness, but now you are light in the Lord.”
—Ephesians 5:8

Spiritual life is not a dimmer switch.
You are not “60% saved,” “half in the kingdom,” or “partially surrendered.”

Your spiritual identity is:

  • 0 — off
  • 1 — on

This is why Jesus says:

“He who is not with Me is against Me.”

You are either:

  • A child of God,
    or
  • Not a child of God.
  • Forgiven,
    or
  • Unforgiven.
  • Born again,
    or
  • Still dead in sin.
  • Light,
    or
  • Darkness.

No third option.
No spiritual spectrum.
No identity middle.

Just like gender.


5. Why the World Rejects Binary Truth

The world hates binary categories because they require submission.

If there are only two genders, we must submit to God’s design.
If there are only two spiritual states, we must submit to Christ’s authority.

Binary truth extinguishes self-worship.
Binary truth eliminates endless identity invention.
Binary truth destroys the illusion of autonomy.

Instead of asking, “Who do I want to be?”
binary truth asks, “Who did God make me to be?”

Instead of asking, “What identity do I create?”
binary truth asks, “Will I follow Christ or reject Him?”

This is why the enemy works so hard to confuse identity.

If you reject physical creation,
you will eventually reject spiritual truth.

If you cannot accept that God made two genders,
you will struggle to accept that God made two eternal destinies.

Identity rebellion leads to spiritual rebellion.

And spiritual rebellion leads to destruction.


6. The Good News: Jesus Turns the Light On

We are all born zeros—
lost, confused, sinful, spiritually dead.

But Jesus came into our darkness
not to shame us
but to save us.

He turns the light switch on.
He restores God’s design.
He brings clarity where the world offers confusion.
He brings identity where culture offers chaos.
He brings truth where society offers illusions.

Jesus is not offering another identity label.
He offers a new birth.

Not a new pronoun.
A new heart.

Not self-definition.
Salvation.

Not self-construction.
Regeneration.

He offers to turn the light on inside of you—permanently.


7. Conclusion: Gender Is Binary. Salvation Is Binary. Christ Is Lord.

The world may invent hundreds of genders,
but Scripture reveals only two.
The world may promote limitless identity options,
but Jesus reveals only two spiritual realities.

God designed creation binary.
Jesus declared salvation binary.
Truth is not fluid.
Identity is not self-created.
Spirituality is not a spectrum.

Life comes down to one question:

Is your light on or off?

Are you with Christ,
or against Him?

There is no third category.

But the hope of the gospel is this:

Though every one of us was born as a zero,
Jesus offers to make us a one
alive, forgiven, redeemed, transformed,
restored in identity, and filled with His light.

Your gender identity is not self-chosen.
Your spiritual identity is not self-built.
Your salvation is not self-earned.

But Jesus stands ready to give you
the identity your soul was made for—
child of God.

All you must do is surrender
to the One who said:

“He who is not with Me is against Me.”

Choose Him.
Choose truth.
Choose life.
Choose light.

Let Him turn your soul on forever.


1 thought on “Non-Binary Is Not in the Bible: The Binary Choice of Christ in Luke 11”

  1. there is a difference between biological sex and gender identity. many wrongly see sex and gender as synonyms. i assume you know gender identity is mostly a social construct. biology doesn’t say boys don’t cry. adults tell them that. biology doesn’t tell us what clothes are masculine/feminine. society does. sometimes it’s just weather, lol. meanwhile, god is presented as anthropomorphic male in the Bible. do you believe God is a man? why do you discount the lives of those who are intersex (Jesus describes several categories in matt. 19:12, including those born that way. even says accept them). galatians tells us there is neither slave nor free, male nor female now that we are one in christ. since i believe jesus was serious about inclusivity and tolerance, i believe a couple things here. galatians reminds us (like jesus told those who questioned him about a woman who had been married to several men) that we are not male and female in heaven. we are like angels. this also remind us that our bodies are not like God’s. that ‘s way too simplistic, don’t you think? and a bit blasphemous. he made us all with a mix of feminine and masculine “qualities” (typically a social construct). the anthropomorphic “He” is a patriarchal culture’s default). our souls/spirits are like God. No one has ever seen that God, so claiming this God is a biology is a mistake. since, God practiced the law of love not the love of law and taught us a Way of doing the same, I always resort to the most loving response. that means inclusive, tolerant, etc.. don’t forget the Bible also thought epilepsy was demonic. we have to remember that God is speaking to the people of a time where our medical advances were centuries upon centuries coming into fruition.

Leave a Reply

Scroll to Top

Discover more from Smith For Christ Blog

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading